Review: Solus 4.4
Most of my experiences with Solus 4.4 were positive ones. The installer was pretty easy to get through, the live environment was nice. I like the look of Budgie and it's fairly easy to navigate. The desktop was responsive and stable, which is always a nice combination. I especially like the Budgie-specific settings panel as it's clearly organized and doesn't overwhelm the user with choices.
Solus ships with a pretty nice collection of default software and I like the software centre. The way it handles third-party software is a little unusual and I was hoping the software centre would support Flatpak, but this doesn't appear to be the case at this time.
There were some problems. As I mentioned above, the theme and application style are not consistent and I think the shared password approach is likely a bug as there isn't a good reason for separate accounts to share a non-root admin password. I also feel as though having two settings panels (with similar names) is likely to cause more confusion than assistance. The biggest problem though was highly unusual: my laptop's sound card not being detected. It is very rare for me to run a Linux distribution which doesn't have working sound. Some systems mute sound or don't offer a mixer control. Solus has the volume turned up, it just can't detect my sound output device on physical hardware. Inside a virtual machine audio worked without any issues.
I was hoping that Solus would introduce some reliability features. The distribution is a rolling release and would benefit from using technologies such as Btrfs and Timeshift to allow users to rollback packages. However, Solus defaults to ext4 for the filesystem and doesn't appear to offer any graphical tools which would help us create or rollback snapshots.
In short, Solus does a lot of things well and often looks really nice and polished with a great collection of applications. But then there are other times when components of the distribution offer a surprisingly jarring contrast or experience - themes not matching, sound not working. There were times when I would find myself considering Solus as being one of the smoother experiences I've had so far in 2023 and the next minute I'd be fuming as I tried to figure out by what logic a user should know to right-click to the right of the file manager top bar in order to open a hidden menu to find preferences that have seemingly already been changed in the settings panel. It was a weird experience and Solus's polish in some areas meant I was repeatedly caught off guard when I ran into problems or inconsistencies in other areas.
I don't know if Solus is here to stay now, or if this is the distribution's swan song after a valiant rescue attempt earlier in the year. I'm hoping it sticks around. I think the project is doing some things well, but it feels as though it just doesn't have the development power behind it yet to make a more consistent, complete experience.