news
Review: Gnoppix AI Linux 25_10
Quoting: DistroWatch.com: Put the fun back into computing. Use Linux, BSD. —
Diving into the Gnoppix experience was, in a word, bizarre. Over the years I have reviewed several distributions which have had technical problems, a handful that have had design issues, and a few which will clearly minimum effort financial schemes to trick people into buying (or donating to) a copy of another distribution with some of the trademarks replaced. Gnoppix is nearly unique in being a project was set up in such a weird way that I questioned what the developers think they were trying to accomplish.
That might seem like a harsh statement, but I struggle to find any other explanation for the Wonderland-style experience Gnoppix offers. The project's website is full of contradictions and misinformation, claiming Gnoppix is lightweight (it's the second- or third-largest distribution by RAM usage I've encountered), it claims to respect privacy by using locally integrated LLMs, but its one AI tool is on-line only and there are no local AI packages, let alone any effort to integrate them in the system.
The project strives to offer a product, a unified AI chat system, but free alternatives are available on-line and downloadable for any Linux distribution without requiring a membership. This calls into the question of the purpose of the Gnoppix AI membership account, which appears to exist solely to make the developers money rather than to offer any benefit to the user.
As I mentioned earlier, the ReadMe file on the desktop is surreal, with rants and claims about Ubuntu being based on Gnoppix, and highlights features which the distribution does not have.
Another thing I found weird is the project's website doesn't appear to mention that Tor is used to redirect the user's network traffic by default. Having Tor enabled as a feature could be good or bad (depending on your needs), but it seems odd to not make it clear that Tor is running automatically. To the project's credit it does mention Tor on the Services page ("The new Gnoppix Tor Bridges feature is designed to combat state-level Internet censorship by providing secret, unlisted entry points into the Tor network.), though it doesn't mention Tor is turned on by default. These "secret entry points" might explain why the Internet connection doesn't work by default. This again feels like an odd thing to do, especially since it has such a negative impact on the distribution's performance.
To top it off, we're greeted by a welcome window that has buttons to launch tools that do not match their labels. It is beyond me why a developer would do this, unless it were for some complex joke.